The Sondern-Adler House, a Frank Lloyd Wright masterpiece in Kansas City, has undergone a significant transformation under new ownership. The Axtells, lifelong admirers of Wright's work, have embarked on a meticulous renovation project, preserving the home's historic beauty while adding their personal touch. This article delves into the fascinating journey of this architectural gem, exploring the Axtells' passion for preservation, the challenges they face, and the impact of their stewardship on this iconic structure.
A Passionate Stewardship
Tom Axtell, a third-generation plumber and a lifelong Wright enthusiast, purchased the Sondern-Adler house in June 2024. His passion for Wright's architecture is evident in his extensive travels, visiting approximately 35 of the architect's structures. Axtell's appreciation for Wright's work is not just aesthetic; it's a connection to a sense of calm and unity. This personal connection to the architect's vision is what drives Axtell's dedication to preserving the Sondern-Adler house.
The Axtells' renovation project is a testament to their commitment to historical preservation. They have undertaken a meticulous process, starting with gutting the kitchen and bathrooms, cleaning the interior brick and woodwork, and installing a new 40-year roof. The couple has also addressed essential systems, including HVAC, plumbing, and electrical work, ensuring the house's functionality and longevity.
Navigating Historic Preservation Challenges
One of the challenges the Axtells face is the historical preservation regulations in Kansas City. The Sondern-Adler house, while not listed on the National Register of Historic Places, is protected locally as part of the Roanoke Historic District. Changes to the exterior and visible features require approval from the city's Historic Preservation Commission, known as 'certificates of appropriateness'.
The Axtells have been proactive in seeking these approvals, consulting with the Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy in Chicago. They have proposed removing a dilapidated storage shed, eliminating a non-original lap pool, modifying an exterior kitchen wall, and regrading part of the property. These changes aim to enhance the house's aesthetics and functionality while respecting its historical significance.
A New Chain Link Fence and Privacy Concerns
A recent development in the Axtells' stewardship has sparked a debate over privacy and preservation. The couple sought permission to replace a crumbling asphalt driveway with concrete and to install a new chain link fence along the north side of their property, adjacent to Roanoke Park. The fence, a replacement for an existing one, has raised concerns about its materiality, as chain link is not typically permitted by the preservation committee.
The Axtells' primary motivation is to protect their private residence from intruders. They have experienced significant intrusion, with vagrants accessing the property from nearby Karnes Boulevard and wandering through the wooded areas. The couple's desire for privacy is understandable, but it has sparked a discussion about the balance between preservation and personal space.
A Legacy of Wright's Architecture in Kansas City
The Sondern-Adler house is one of only three Wright structures in Kansas City. Wright's influence in the city extends beyond this single masterpiece. In 1940, he was commissioned to design the Community Christian Church, located near the Country Club Plaza. This early connection to Wright's work in Kansas City highlights the architect's enduring impact on the city's architectural landscape.
Conclusion: A Legacy Preserved
The Axtells' stewardship of the Sondern-Adler house is a testament to their passion for historical preservation and their appreciation for Frank Lloyd Wright's architectural legacy. Their meticulous renovation project not only restores the house's original grandeur but also ensures its longevity for future generations. As they navigate the challenges of preservation, the Axtells' dedication to this iconic structure serves as an inspiration for all who value the preservation of architectural heritage.
